Cracking the Code: The Most Common Supplemental Essay Types (and How to Approach Them)

Just when students finish the main Common App essay and start to relax, the supplemental prompts appear. These school-specific prompts might feel like busywork, but they actually serve an important purpose: they help colleges figure out fit. Unlike the personal statement, which shows who you are, supplements show why you belong on that specific campus.

Here are the most common types—and how to approach each one strategically:

1. “Why This College?”

This is easily the most common supplemental essay. Schools want to know if you’ve done your homework and genuinely understand what they offer. They’re also checking whether your goals and interests align with their programs, culture, or values.

What to focus on: Be specific. Don’t just name-drop professors or majors—connect those elements to you. For example, instead of saying “I want to study biology at X University,” you could write, “X’s focus on undergraduate research, especially in Professor Lin’s neurogenetics lab, aligns with my long-term goal of studying rare brain disorders.”

2. Community or Identity Essays

Some schools ask about the communities you come from or the identities that have shaped your perspective. This helps them understand your background and the voice you’ll bring to campus. 

What to focus on: Be honest and reflective. This isn’t about having a dramatic story—it’s about showing how your lived experiences inform how you think, lead, collaborate, or support others. Show how those aspects of your identity influence what you care about and how you engage with the world.

3. Academic Interest or “Why This Major?”

These essays dig deeper into your intellectual interests. Colleges want to know how you’ve explored your intended field and how you plan to continue doing so.

What to focus on: Tell a story of curiosity. What sparked your interest? What have you done to pursue it? Link your past experiences (courses, projects, internships) to the school's future opportunities, like specific classes, faculty, or research centers.

4. Extracurricular or “How Do You Spend Your Time?”

This is a chance to show depth beyond your activities list. Schools are trying to understand how you use your free time and what energizes you.

What to focus on: Don’t just repeat your résumé. Instead, focus on why the activity matters and what you’ve learned or contributed through it. Show passion, growth, or leadership in action.

Bottom line? Every supplemental essay is a window into how you think and how you’ll fit into a school’s ecosystem. Be specific, be reflective, and above all—be yourself. Schools aren’t looking for perfect—they’re looking for thoughtful, self-aware students who will contribute meaningfully to campus life. For more help writing your supplemental essays, check out Resume All Day’s essay coaching services.

College Essay Coaching